Friday, March 6, 2009

The Chick Who Could Have Been....

Sometime last week we had quite an interesting experiment happen in our management class. The minute I walked into class I saw a carton of egg, straws, tape, and a huge garbage bin smacked in the middle of class.

While Professor Kurpis waited patiently for the eager class to settle down, he finally spoke and with a voice of a lions might he told the class what was about to take place. As you would have guessed, these egg
s were not meant to be eaten, but rather their fates were to be toyed with by our very own hands. The class was divided into several divisions, and each of them were to be given 2 feet of tape, 8 straws and an egg. Now for the most gruesome part, our job, was to create some sort of contraption that would allow the egg to survive a 10 feet drop to its death. We only had 10 minutes to come up with a design and 25 minutes to put that said design into action. To make matters worse there was only ONE scissor to go around and so many eggs to be saved.

Then without a minutes notice and a click from Professor Kurpis, the timer had started, and our Egg's fate to be decided with every passing second. I was quite enthusiastic about this whole experiment, and without a second to lose, I tried
to reassure our group that I had a nail clipper that could have been used as a replacement for scissors...until I was ruthlessly turned down by one of our members, who then began to share her idea for the contraption, but little did we know her idea was all we were going to hear about. At that moment all enthusiasm I had for this assignment was lost, and that was how the first step of our planning process began.

While our group was listening to our dictator explain her idea, we all wondered if we had enough resources to even produce this idea of hers. Each of us tried to suggest an alternative or tell her the problems we could be running into, but we were ignored until someone said something she found helpful and thus at that point we all just tried to build upon her idea and gave up finding alternatives...except for I. That was how step 2 and 3 of the process came about. Not too exciting.

At this moment our 10 minutes of planning was up and it was time to place the plan(s) into action. Then with a mighty press of his finger Professor Kurpis started the 25 minute countdown, and our poor eggs came closer to their impeding doom. Each of us immediately went to work, but with so many hands and only one egg, many of us didn't really participate in the production of the contraption. Though we did try to make everyone feel special by assigning them a role, we even went as far as to give someone the role to watch the egg making sure the egg doesn't crack as it sits silently on the table. Oh how time flies with a blink of an eye. The 25 minutes were up before we knew it and it was time to let go of our eggs. As each group got up on the table and nervously dropped their eggs into the bin, some spinning, some misguided, some never even made it. It was finally our turn to go, and as we got ready to drop the egg everyone was baffled by our design, some felt cheated others applauded, but without a seconds hesitation we dropped the egg. Our egg managed to avoid its death but its many siblings did not.

Overall i didn't feel like our group was much of a group, more like a dictatorship, with one leader, and one plan; her plan. I felt it would have been nice if we were able to voice our opinions without being shunned or ignored like we were non existent, but ultimately we managed to succeed, and that's what the assignment was all about. succeeding, not.

5 comments:

  1. Well, there are 2 ways to look at this situation.

    1) She took the role of leading and guided the team to a win

    2) Your opinions were not well communicated therefore leading you to think they were ignored

    In cases like this, you need to take demand and have your opinions heard. The way she was managing by not allowing her peers to speak is not effective and more than likely, inefficient. You have explained your disappointment towards her being the only leader and I would guess the reason why you didn't address this during the activity is because you were upset and didn't maintain composure. I am pretty sure that next time around you will analyze the situation-her not allowing others to voice out opinions- and also take up a leadership role and make sure everybody has a say in the project. There is no hierarchy within our classmates so there should be no reason why you feel the group was under dictatorship.

    One thing I do like that was done in your group is the fact that you assigned everyone a role. Even though it may seem the role of "watching the egg while planning to make sure it doesn't break," may seem stupid, it is indeed the most important role. Why? Well if that role was not successfully managed, the best of plans would have gone to waste if the egg would have broke during the drawing up of the plan. You would have failed before even being tested.

    That's my 2 cents : )

    Francis Cho

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hopefully next time both of us can be in a group without a dictator. It really bothers me when people believe they are better or have the ability to talk down to others. Who gave them the authority??!
    Anyways, instead of being bummed out about that dictator theres another way to look at the situation, you received FIVE points on that extremely difficult exam! (the grass is always greener on the other side.) While other eggs broke, our egg did succeed. It went on to become someone's breakfast the next morning. HAHA

    ReplyDelete
  3. awww~ well at least your egg made it!! and you got the five points! but I know what you mean. Many people tend to be very bossy and just do not listen or even try to listen to the other group members. They just take a charge and make the group members follow her/his plan. I am suprised that it worked though. Hope you can find a better group next time!

    ReplyDelete
  4. well, first of all, good job. as i was reading this, i was very excited with the story. because, well, i knew where it was getting to in the beginning. obviously there was something wrong
    but also because as a former science olympian, the egg drop is a task that me and my fellow 7th and 8th graders had to do as kids. except our drop was more like 50 feet. lols
    and it was very nostalgic to read your story. it brings back so many memories. btw, my contraption did not work back then ): so be proud of yurself.. or rather.. you dont because it was only her, huh?
    maybe thats why youre so upset. not bcuz she wouldnt listen to you guys. but because she didnt listen and thought of something that was probably better than what you couldve contributed?
    a sense of worthlessness + shame, maybe?
    mentally degrading even though she probably didnt mean it.
    anyways, im not saying youre wrong. you hav every right to be upset. but maybe thats just her personality. she cant help but be the "leader" of the pack. sometimes people dont realize this and maybe she didnt bcuz she was so excited about the project.
    anyways, this is getting mad long. so cheer up (:
    go back to baking some goodies. youre always so happy when you do (:

    ReplyDelete
  5. ;O You blog?!

    I'd write more but I'm starting to feel dead tired right now. ;x Toodles dear.

    ReplyDelete